andy hall ([info]hallawayjoe) wrote,
@ 2008-08-04 16:50:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Gonna Whine!
Not having an assistantship while going for my PhD is really tough.

I am in debt.
I have an old car.
Not part of Grad school/GA community
Not getting as much access to professors: mentorship, friendship, etc..
Having to work off campus.
Blow to ego, confidence and self esteem.

But consolations:

*Colleage at work tells me it is all a popularity contest.
*Another peer tells me that I (including him) just don't have the connections.
* Mom tells me that a third of all positions don't materialize due to lack of funding, another third are nepotistic or given to friends of the those in power, and the rest of us are fighting over that last third.
* My partner tells me that they use the positions to lure people in and since I am already here, why fund me since I have few other options?
*My advisor says I don't have the GPA, yet I was good enough for NAU and Antioch... just not here.

So my obsession with being locked out/left out of the Country Club of academia continues

But I can console myself realizing that I only have another year or two where I have to stay here then I can finish my dissertation elsewhere.

I will have the pride knowing that I completed this degree under trying circumstances, and worked harder than most of the other students.

My perceptions are probably distorted, and unrealistic, but this is how I feel.

I think I deserve better.
I can pat myself on the back and carry on.

As bad as things may seem
At least I am not in Iraq
or in prison
or dead.

I am pouting... other people have it worse, much worse.

But I still expect things to be a little more smooth for me.

At least I would like some success in my field for all the anguish I am putting myself through.

Enough whining... I am going to go stuff my face with popcorn and watch Will Smith deal with it all.



(Post a new comment)

My replies. . .
[info]electricmystery
2008-08-06 06:07 am UTC (link)
I am in debt.
*Join the club. It sucks. :(

I have an old car.
*Mine is a little newer than yours, but we have 2 incomes and it's cheap. I bet yours cost more.

Not part of community
*Anyone at THAT school in THAT Department who doesn't kiss ass or have the "proper connections" is not part of the "Elite Community" which is who they think they are. I don't think they are. I'd rather be friends with you because you don't talk just to hear your own voice. You care about students. You care about people. You would never make me feel degraded or demoralized. THEY do. A LOT. And I am supposedly an assistant professor. Of course, that doesn't matter because I don't have a Ph.D., ya know.

Not getting as much access to professors
*As far as mentorship, are you sure you're being aggressive enough? Also, have you considered an NTT? I know a kick ass one who is a creative writer with the degrees to prove it. You don't need to find your friendship there, although seemingly convenient and helpful, sometimes it is actually neither.

Having to work off campus.
*Okay, yes, that sucks hardcore. HOWEVER, you are well respected by your students and have received great reviews from this job!

Blow to ego, confidence and self esteem.
*This is an understandable reaction and I don't blame you one bit. All I have to say is, at least you got in. Some people didn't even get into a school at all. And, you're so much better than that. Why do you care what they think? Really. . .why? They used to be adjuncts or NTT's and now they seriously attack and demoralize those who are in their former positions. I am totally serious. You have no idea what goes on. YOU are more of a human being to them than I, or any of my colleagues that aren't married to a tenured professor are.

But consolations:

Colleague at work tells me it is all a popularity contest.
*I agree! The world never leaves high school. . .err middle school. . .err grade school mentality!

don't have the connections.
*Also agree. Unless you know someone who knows someone, it's really hard even at the M.A. level!

Mom tells me that a third of all positions don't materialize due to lack of funding, another third are nepotistic or given to friends of the those in power, and the rest of us are fighting over that last third.
*You have a smart mom. :)

My partner tells me that they use the positions to lure people in and since I am already here, why fund me since I have few other options?
*You have a smart partner. :) This is SO true. Remember my friend that came and visited? It's only because they were offering her an assistantship. She HATED it and is going to Georgia w/o an assistantship (which they only give out to second year students). This is VERY true.

My advisor says I don't have the GPA
*Our state has no money. Our governor is keeping it in his bedroom and having sex with it every night. Seriously. They don't have the money and they don't give a shit. It's probably just because of the time you applied and this is just your advisor's excuse to get you to stop bugging him/her. They could've filled all the spots before you applied or they could've had people with "connections" and decided to give them assistantships first. Half the things that people say are excuses around there. Sometimes they don't know that they're excuses, but everyone is covering for someone else. . .and it all leads back to suckiness. It could be situational/coincidental. You should feel good about getting offered those assistantships at those other schools (which are very good ones)!

YOU ARE AN INTELLIGENT, COMPASSIONATE, FUNNY, AMAZING PERSON. WHILE THIS MAY SUCK NOW, WHEN YOU ARE FINISHED, WILL THIS REALLY MATTER? DON'T LET YOUR WORK/SCHOOL SITUATION DEFINE YOU. YOU ARE SO MUCH MORE THAN THAT! YOU ARE SO MUCH BETTER THAN THAT!

So, chin up! You're good at being mad at "the man," but turn that energy into something positive. Turn it into creative energy. Write, dance, sing, teach with the passion that I know you do. Maybe your reward is not here, but is waiting for you when you get a kick ass job that none of those other people do. You *do* have the teaching experience. You *will* be okay. I believe in you and you should too!

(((HUGS)))

(Reply to this)

P.S.
[info]electricmystery
2008-08-06 06:10 am UTC (link)
If you want to whine some more, I'll be happy to listen because I like hanging out with you at our local hangout. :) I'm not insinuating that whining should never be done. :P

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: P.S.
(Anonymous)
2008-08-06 10:22 pm UTC (link)
Thanks!

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Re: P.S.
[info]hallawayjoe
2008-08-06 10:23 pm UTC (link)
Thanks J!

(Reply to this) (Parent)

your program
[info]debthegrouch
2008-08-11 01:58 am UTC (link)
sounds kinda like my job, you know? I say that even though of course I have the kind of job you wish they had given you. In the current economic climate, I'm glad and grateful to have a job at all, so I'm at least in a way not complaining, but after all, this is the job you quit to go back to school, so I think you know what I mean. Pretty demoralizing in most regards, no contact with the full-timers, who were my friends/colleagues when I first worked here, no room for creativity, no choice in what I teach or how I teach it, very little respect for having the ability to do the job I'm hired to do, and no job security. I too feel very isolated, and cannot afford to own even an old car because I'm a single parent; in fact, some of my peers who also do not own cars aren't parents and have no expenses for anyone but themselves. At least you have a partner. Mazal tov, and may the same be true for me some day. That's a very big plus, Andy. Celebrate it every time you feel down.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: your program
[info]hallawayjoe
2008-08-19 06:16 pm UTC (link)
Thanks Deb,

I think a lot of it is just depression. I am reading a book by the Dalai Lama on Happiness. Gratitude is key.

Love,

Andy

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…